0American Idol Should's and Should Not'sAfter another lackluster week, Maura Johnston on what's ailing American Idol. Plus, VIEW OUR GALLERY of contestants who should have—and should not have—gotten to the Top 12.Updated Jul. 14, 2017 12:33PM EDT / Published Mar. 24, 2010 2:13PM EDT Frank Micelotta / FOX, Lilly Scott: Why She Was WorthyFrank Micelotta / FOX Aaron Kelly: Why He Should Have Packed His BagsFrank Micelotta / FOX Alex Lambert: Why He Was WorthyFrank Micelotta / FOX Katie Stevens: Why She Should Have Packed Her BagsFrank Micelotta / FOX John Park: Why He Was WorthyFrank Micelotta / FOX Andrew Garcia: Why He Should Have Packed His BagsFrank Micelotta / FOX Angela Martin: Why She Was WorthyMichael Becker / Picture Group Tim Urban: Why He Should Have Packed His BagsFrank Micelotta / FOX Michael Castro: Why He Was Worthy Didi Benami: Why She Should Have Packed Her BagsFrank Micelotta / FOX Rose Flack: Why She Was WorthyMichael Becker / Picture Group Paige Miles: Why She Should Have Packed Her Bags (Earlier Than Wednesday Night)Frank Micelotta / FOX
Lilly Scott: Why She Was WorthyFrank Micelotta / FOX Aaron Kelly: Why He Should Have Packed His BagsFrank Micelotta / FOX Alex Lambert: Why He Was WorthyFrank Micelotta / FOX Katie Stevens: Why She Should Have Packed Her BagsFrank Micelotta / FOX John Park: Why He Was WorthyFrank Micelotta / FOX Andrew Garcia: Why He Should Have Packed His BagsFrank Micelotta / FOX Angela Martin: Why She Was WorthyMichael Becker / Picture Group Tim Urban: Why He Should Have Packed His BagsFrank Micelotta / FOX Michael Castro: Why He Was Worthy Didi Benami: Why She Should Have Packed Her BagsFrank Micelotta / FOX Rose Flack: Why She Was WorthyMichael Becker / Picture Group Paige Miles: Why She Should Have Packed Her Bags (Earlier Than Wednesday Night)Frank Micelotta / FOX