Photo Illustration by Elizabeth Brockway/The Daily Beast
Choose Your Own Adventure!

Inside the GOP’s Plan to ‘Skinny Repeal’ Obamacare

The GOP won the right to debate their health-care bill on Tuesday. Now they need to figure out what will actually pass.

Andrew Desiderio, Sam Stein7.25.17 9:10 PM ET

Senate Republican leaders scored a significant victory on Tuesday in the fight to repeal and replace Obamacare by getting a majority of senators to agree to begin debate on a mystery bill.

But the path forward is uncertain at best, with party leadership still forced to navigate internal policy disputes, anger over a disjointed legislative process, and the prospect that House Republicans may very well reject anything they push through the Senate chamber.

And even if the Senate sends a bill back to the House, the leading proposal may face resistance from key conservatives there. One such lawmaker suggested to The Daily Beast that House conservatives won’t simply vote “yes” on anything the Senate sends them.

“I think it is a binary choice—is that what we’ve heard before? Binary choices are really good in Congress. They work for monkeys and computers?” Rep. Raul Labrador (R-ID) told The Daily Beast. “Oh wait, was I being sarcastic?”

He was.

“No,” he added, when asked if the House will simply swallow what the Senate produces. “You’ve got to give freedom to the states at a minimum. In my opinion, we should get rid of the entire bill—the entire Obamacare—but that’s not going to happen... This is our one chance to repeal Obamacare and to give the states flexibility.”

Reflecting the tough path still ahead, GOP leaders spent little time on self-congratulation following Tuesday’s vote. Instead, they began gaming out the next few days of legislative activity, which will involve consideration of a host of amendments, numerous—potentially tricky —votes, and arcane parliamentary procedures. Making the path even trickier is the impossibly small margin for error with which they must now work.

Just 50 of the 52 Republican senators voted in favor of the procedural measure to open debate on a health care bill, with moderate Sens. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK) and Susan Collins (R-ME) and all Democrats voting against it. Vice President Mike Pence had to be brought in to break the tie and that was after Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) was summoned back to Washington to vote on the measure, just one week after he was diagnosed with brain cancer. McCain was given a hero’s welcome and a standing ovation in the legislative body where he’s served for three decades.

But even as he cast the deciding vote to proceed to debate, he made it clear that his support for the end-product shouldn’t be taken for granted.

“We’ve tried to do this by coming up with a proposal behind closed doors, in consultation with the administration—and then springing it on skeptical members, trying to convince them that it’s better than nothing,” McCain said. “Asking us to swallow our doubts and force it past a unified opposition? I don’t think that is going to work in the end. And it probably shouldn’t.”

Neither Democratic nor Republican lawmakers and aides said on Tuesday that they definitively knew whether the chamber would actually pass a final bill. But the expectations for doing so have notably brightened in recent days.

On Tuesday, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell was able to effectively persuade his members that it was vital to move forward with debate even without knowing exactly what health care legislation the body was to consider. He is expected to make the same pitch for the final vote: encouraging Republicans to get some, any, bill into a conference committee with the House so that the process can simply continue.

What lawmakers will ultimately vote on is not entirely clear, though Republican aides previewed to The Daily Beast a final product that would repeal the individual and employer mandates as well as the tax on medical device manufacturers while leaving in place Obamacare’s Medicaid expansion. Known as a “skinny repeal,” the legislation, according to the Congressional Budget Office, would still leave an estimated 15 million people uninsured by 2026. But, according to aides, it represents the best possible vehicle—at least at this juncture—for the Senate to move forward.

And even that might be an impossible task.

Though Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) has indicated that he would drop his conservative-minded opposition to a “skinny repeal” bill provided he got a vote on full repeal beforehand, other conservatives—in both houses of Congress—may still vote no. (Labrador told The Daily Beast that he would not support a so-called “skinny repeal.”) On Tuesday night, Paul was already teasing the clean repeal bill, adding it will come to a vote on Wednesday.

Both Collins and Murkowski have remained consistent in their opposition to Senate Republicans’ approach to health care reform both on policy and process. Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.V.), who dropped prior opposition to side with leadership on Tuesday, said just last week that she would “only vote to proceed to repeal legislation if I am confident there is a replacement plan that addresses my concerns.” It’s not clear if a “skinny repeal” would do that.

McCain has called for a return to a legislative process that involves congressional committees and Democrats. Whether that, or his health, precludes him from backing the final bill is anyone’s guess. In his speech on the Senate floor, he said would consult with his home state’s governor, Doug Ducey, before voting.

Ultimately, however, the threat of being blamed for doing nothing may outweigh specific concerns with the final piece of legislation—whether that’s “skinny repeal” or something else. That’s the card that President Trump has played, successfully, in the run-ups to the House and Senate votes.

“Any senator who votes against starting debate is telling America that you are fine with the Obamacare nightmare,” the president said Monday at the White House.

And momentum is now definitively on the Republican party’s side. Leaders are aiming to finish the process by the end of this week and send a bill to the House, which is scheduled to begin its August recess next week. Speaker Paul Ryan (R-WI) has pledged that the House would remain in session if the Senate sends over a bill.

“We’re going to stay and finish health care,” Ryan previously said.

Cheat Sheet®

The 10 Most Important Stories Right Now


    Trump: ‘Time Will Tell’ if Sessions Stays

    Attorney General on the bubble.


    House Overwhelmingly Passes New Sanctions Against Russia

    The bill passed by a margin of 419 to 3.


    Rick Perry Held 22-Minute Call With Fake Ukrainian Official

    The energy secretary fell for Russian pranksters impersonating the Ukrainian prime minister.

  4. 4. Advertisement

    How Kodak's 180° Security Camera Provides You Peace of Mind

    Ad by Daily Beast Shop


    Report: Sessions Preparing to Announce Several Leak Probes

    After Trump publicly scolds him for not being “tough” enough.

  6. 6. SCANDAL

    Ex-Fox News Exec Sues Company for $48M Over Assault Claims

    He says he was used as a scapegoat to show the network was fighting sexual harassment.

  7. 7. HALT

    Senate Judiciary Committee Rescinds Subpoena for Manafort

    Committee still in talks to have him appear in private.

  8. 8. PLAN AHEAD

    Ivanka Trump Hires Defense Lawyer for Russia Probe

    Abbe Lowell will provide legal and ethical advice.

  9. 9. R.I.P.

    U.S. High School Graduate Died in Tractor-Trailer

    Tried to get back to his family near Washington.

  10. 10. IMPACT

    Study: 99% of Examined NFL Players’ Brains Have CTE

    Significant evidence that repeated head trauma can cause degenerative disease.

ISIS Turns its Guns—and Propaganda Machine—on Iran

Wyden: When It Comes to Trumpkins—‘Follow the Money’